chevron-right
News  | 

SZK secures Small Claims Court Trial Win in s. 95 Bankruptcy Preference Action

Overview

Spetter Zeitz Klaiman is pleased to share a successful result obtained by Cora Madden on behalf of judgment creditors Shahram Heidari, Tarra Engineering Inc., and Tarra Engineering and Structural Consultants Inc.

After securing judgments exceeding $920,000 against the bankrupt debtor, our clients discovered that, less than a year before bankruptcy, the debtor had repaid $20,000 to his spouse while other creditors went unpaid. Our clients then obtained an order under s. 38 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (the “BIA”) to challenge the repayment as a preferential payment in contravention of s. 95 of the BIA.

The defendant attempted to explain away the transaction at trial, but Deputy Judge Anschell found her evidence inconsistent with prior bankruptcy examination testimony and gave that evidence “very little weight.”

The Court held that the repayment constituted a non-arm's length preference under section 95 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, declared the payment void, and ordered repayment of the full $20,000, together with prejudgment interest, post-judgment interest, and costs.

This decision is a reminder that transfers to family members and other non-arm's-length creditors are subject to close scrutiny when insolvency is on the horizon. Creditors are not powerless when preferential payments diminish the estate available for distribution.

Congratulations to Cora Madden, whose careful use of bankruptcy examination transcripts and focused trial advocacy helped secure a complete victory for her clients.

Called to the Bar in 2023 and a graduate of McGill University's J.D./B.C.L. program, Cora continues to build an impressive litigation practice, including work in creditor remedies, insolvency-related disputes, and fraud recovery matters.